4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


5 Disadvantages of Static Electric Dog Collars

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » 5 Disadvantages of Static Electric Dog Collars

Higher Initial Cost

The investment price for a static shock-proof dog collar can be several times higher than a traditional collar. Static collars can vary in range, water resistance, and stimulation level, and a decent training tool will cost you $30-$200. The above information refers to other tools, clickers, or snack-based systems that typically cost less than $10.

Short and long term cost implications

Although prices may vary depending on the store and service, price is irrelevant when analyzing affordability for the effectiveness of a shock collar. While this may be a quick fix to the problem, using a static ring can result in high long-term costs. Because the battery in an electrostatic collar works for a certain period of time, the battery must be replaced regularly. It is planned that if a shock collar is accidentally used as a jerk, it will result in the cost of paying a veterinarian to help the pet, as well as the cost of hiring a qualified dog trainer. Other tools don’t use electronic energy, don’t harm living things, and don’t require special skills to work with pets.

Comparison with non-electronic training tools

Non-electronic tools can work without involving any monetary outlay. They may also help develop traits such as socialization, protectiveness between owner and pet, and affectionate and caring behavior in dogs.

Economic analysis of training options

The average price per dog training session is $50, but most basic behavioral problems can be solved in 5-10 sessions, which equates to $250-500, which means using traditional tools is not only more efficient, but also better than electronic ones More affordable.

Stigma of Shock Collars

There is a vast stigma surrounding the use of static shock collars in dog training. They are often seen as cruel or lazy training methods by the public and professionals alike. A study conducted in 2012 showed that “88.7% of 1,020 people interviewed thought animal training should be partly or completely based on the use of positive reinforcement. Only 59.7% felt that aversive techniques could prove to be a useful part of a training program.” The majority of pet owners and professional trainers prefer and employ positive reinforcement techniques over any other type encountered.

Influence of the Public and Reaction of the Community

Public opinion plays a substantial role when it comes to taking care of pets. The 2012 survey showed that about “68% of the people consider electric shock collars in application to an animal as inhumane ”. It means that when using these devices, an owner is to experience various types of negative social interactions, including sideward glances, disagreements, open confrontation, or prompts to leave and then not return to parks, training classes, and other places with one’s pets.

Impact on Adopting and Rescue Organizations

Many animal shelters and rescues do not allow adopting their animals if an owner plans to use a shock collar. This tendency can be partially explained by the humane treatment of animals and an overall philosophy that employs positive reinforcement techniques. This notion can drastically limit an owner’s choice of places where they may adopt their furry friend; People working at such facilities may become aware of shock collar users and stop approaching them altogether.

Influence on the Owner-Dog Relationship

From the psychological point of view, the relationship between an owner and their pet becomes damaged. According to a study conducted in the United Kingdom, dogs trained with electric shock and other aversive methods develop fear-related behaviors. These behaviors can ruin the level of trust between a pet and an owner. To restore it, one has to put a considerable amount of time and effort, which might be substantially more than if the distrusting dog was trained with positive reinforcement from the very start.

Ongoing Battery Costs

Something that is often overlooked when discussing shock collars is the ongoing cost of their batteries. Depending on the model, these will either require a special set of disposable batteries or a proprietary rechargeable battery pack. The cost of maintenance is as follows:

  • A good disposable battery costs around $5-15. Let’s suppose that one replacement would cost around $10. That is around $30-40 a year and possibly more, but a fair lower estimate would be a smaller number of around $20.
  • The cost of a rechargeable battery is harder to estimate because it is solely dependent on how long it will end up lasting you. However, even a powerful rechargeable battery would only last you around five years need to be replaced, and a lower quality one would likely hold a charge for 3 or so years. A reasonable estimate for one battery’s cost would be around $30-50, which would also be its cost as a separate unit. Even if it can be assumed that the battery can be replaced after ten years, that’s still $30.
  • The cost of the replacement charger would be around $20 and its lifespan would run in line with the battery’s lifespan of ten years.

Other than the financial cost, the environmental cost of throwing away batteries is non-negligible. Anything chargeable does not need to be thrown away into hazardous waste, but even rechargeable batteries are not endless. Both disposable and chargeable batteries are expensive compared to another way of training dogs. With most tools for moving dogs being non-electronic – such as harnesses, living and choker chains or leashes – the cost of a tool is the a same as its acquisition. Over its lifespan, the financial and environmental cost of its batteries will exceed that of a quality training multiple times.

Requires Careful Handling

Static shock collars require delicate handling and precise settings to prevent harm to the dog. Misuse or misadjustment can have negative consequences both physical and behavioral.

Overcorrection Risks

If the setting is too high, the distress or pain might be significantly more than necessary. A minor misbehaviour might be punished by a shock that is too strong. The dog might become so frightened or mistrustful of the handler that the training becomes ineffective. In many cases, the relations between the dog and its owner can become severely damaged. Proper safety mechanisms and programming might prevent this to some degree, but the risks are ever-present.

Training Types and Skill Requirement

The proper use of the shock collar is relatively straightforward from the technical standpoint, but the handler must exhibit a consistent approach to its use. Many devices are programmed to punish a particular type of behavior, via a sound or shock notification, and any other misbehaviours have to be handled manually by theer handler’s intervention. This may lead to the dog’s confusion of what behaviour is being punished based on the inconsistency of response. The handler has to be highly-skilled. Depending on their ability some handlers might require training or assistance to use a static collar. It is also a safety concern, as the extra cost of using professionals must be included in the general shape of the device system.

Not Suitable for All Dogs

There are a great number of ways in which static shock collars may not fit every dog in every case. Breeds, temperaments, and health conditions should all be taken into appropriate consideration.

Breed and Size Dynamics

One size definitely does not fit all, and this certainly holds true for the use of shock collars on dogs. Some breeds or simply dogs with smaller sizes should never be trained using shocks even on the lowest settings. In one study, which utilized a wide variety of dog breeds, Researcher Jonathan J. Cooper found that smaller dogs such as Chihuahuas and Bichons were more stressed in response to the static shocks than larger breeds like Labradors and Shepherds. Trainers should absolutely consider the physical size, as well as the potential more breed-specific mood imbalances associated with certain breeds, before contacting a shock training supplier.

Effects on Fearful and Aggressive Dogs

Affected dogs, especially when they are anxious or fearful-prone, do not take well to training with shock collars. In the case of shocks or surprise pain on such animals, these timid dogs tend to get more anxious. In one case in which a dog was caged with other potential trainees, and had to listen to the negative vocalized responses of these other dogs to shocks, the caged dog became so aggressive that it was no longer able to be adopted down the line. Veterinarians typically recommend that dog trainers in these cases build up their dogs’ internal trust and confidence otherwise.

Physical Health

Many dog owners may not realize that shocks can even be dangerous to certain dogs’ health conditions, particularly heart conditions or severe skin conditions. Introducing an electrical force or pulse can doom the dog owner to trips to the vet and potential heart and skin issues such as pacemaker interference and skin shock dermatitis.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account