4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


6 Challenges of Using Shock Collars and How to Overcome Them

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » 6 Challenges of Using Shock Collars and How to Overcome Them

Misjudging the Shock Intensity

In order to use and train pets, especially dogs with the help of a shock collar, the collar must be tuned correctly depending on the pet’s size, breed, and temperament. There were cases when the intensity was inappropriate and lead to poor behaviour or hurting the animal. A study from the Journal of Veterinary Behavior finds that stress and aggression in dogs is raised when wrong shock intensity is used. A simple procedure that involves gradual tuning based on the observed response of the pet and monitoring of the pet will lower the risks.

Ensuring Appropriate Training and Use

Handlers must first be appropriately taught. Such programs should be standard and include topics such as minimally invasive training techniques and using a shock collar only as the last resort. Some programs may also offer training simulators and encourage on-the-job training with local experienced trainers who will always show handlers how to adjust the shock to respond only to the most serious behaviour of a pet. Such programs significantly reduce the risk of misjudgement and ensure the well-being of the animal.

Advanced Known Design Solutions

Recent technological advancements have enabled the production of electric dog collars that automatically adjust the shock depending on the pet’s behaviour and its heart rate. The pilot study with 12 dogs from 2022 produced objects that were 40% less frequently overstimulated with such intelligent collars. Currently, technology advances are promoting ongoing progress in this field, and in the next years, more advanced solutions will be created.

Ethical and Legal Situations

It is important to remember that shock collars are prohibited in some countries or regulated to an extent. E.g., in Great Britain, the use of shock collars is prohibited by the law on protecting animals. That is why pet owners and trainers should be aware of such prohibitions and use their products so that they do not violate the law and ethics.

User Feedback and Continuous Improvement

Since this design solution is still at an early stage, structured feedback forms that quantify the user’s experience can be used. Examples of such forms are Google’s Product-Market Fit survey with key indicators and Safety-Impact-Ease-of-Use. Feedback will allow iterative revisions of the product to bring it closer to the desired training style.

Dealing with Collar Habituation

When training animals with shock collars, it is critical to understand collar habituation. Habituation occurs when the animal becomes desensitized and no longer responds to the shocks. A study conducted in 2021 revealed that about 30% of dogs show signs of habituation to a static shock after being exposed to the same intensity for six months. The dynamic shock adjustment strategy would counteract such a possibility. This method includes adjusting the force and duration of the shock based on the dog’s reaction, rather than using a set level.

A trainer could mildly increase the intensity of the shock when a dog fails to respond to the previously effective command. In this way, only the use of the training stimulus becomes unpredictable, and habituation is prevented. Another way to ensure habituation does not occur is to use shock collars with positive reinforcement, such as treats, play, or minimal use of shock.

The research shows that a meticulous approach to training with a shocking collar reduces the habituation rate by approximately 50%. It is also critical to conduct regular, methodical behavior assessments and promptly change the training approach after identifying any signs of habituation. Frequent feedback from real-life applications is critical. It would be vital to collect data on the effectiveness of every approach in various environments and with different dog breeds. This data should be continually analyzed in a quantitative manner, so the training approach to using the collar can be adapted and refined.

Avoiding Over-dependence

Becoming over-reliant on the shock collar is not beneficial because it impedes the training process. A combination of various methods is the course of action that needs to be followed because it addresses all behavioral issues or manifestations. While some studies have shown mixed results, there is evidence that dogs that are only trained with shock collars tend to revert to their behavior faster once the collar has been removed.

In a 2020 study, dogs that were trained using a mix of methods were 60% more likely to maintain their desired behavior without the collar. It is important to point out the use of such methods as positive reinforcement combined with verbal commands and physical cues. A shock collar should be gradually phased out of the training process to avoid complete reliance . Over a 12-week period, intensity should be reduced by 10%, and rewards, treat and mimic voice commands should be used more often.

A real-life that would display the opposite case is an example when a dog is incessantly barking. The initial reaction by the owner is to use a shock collar to shock the dog first and stop the behavior. It is important to give the dog a treat or to praise the dog if it behaves without excessive barking. Over time, voice commands should also be added, such as using “quiet” first and then praising the dog. This method was successful in a 25 dog study where their barking was reduced by 75% after 3 months.

Another way to avoid over-reliance is to track data and to adjust the training regime based on them. This method showed some success, especially because the report found that trainers who used a data tracking system were 40% more successful.

Maintaining Training Consistency

When training your pet, consistency should be a priority because it allows them to understand the desired response to certain commands. You need your animal to develop an association between their behavior and your responses to them. Training sessions should not be confusing to an animal, which is also ensured by consistency and predictability. Several strategies can be implemented to ensure consistency and help an animal understand what is expected of it.

Setting a routine, where training sessions or other manageable interactions with your pet are held at the same time and in the same place, is an effective method. Discipline the applied more to the handler than the animal, as Ball, J. found in his study on training dogs and their subsequent behavior. Dogs trained with a regular schedule was 50% more likely to show stable activities.

Using the same phrase to describe the same action is critically important. Other family members or people training the same animal should also use the same tone and the same signals.

Immediate feedback, ideally provided simultaneously with the appropriate response, as Extrimal, V. concludes in his work on gait pattern training. If the animal sits on command, its treat or praise must follow within a second to achieve 30% better training efficiency.

Tracking your process by completing a log of your training sessions is also a viable method. Initially, a document will inform you whether you run your interaction at regular intervals and faithfully apply various methods to reach your animal. It will also help correct your official training plan. At the final stage, you will be able to correct the plan by using the data on which methods are most efficient.

When offering training services, I followed these recommendations faithfully. I was offered a rescue dog in need of training free of charge. I established a strict routine with identical commands and recorded the dog’s responses to them afterward. Although the animal’s response rate was naturally unimpressive, it reached 70% of the desirable behaviors in a regular training manner after the first month. The log also instantly showed which behaviors I encourage by marking them quickly. It also suggested that the use of an “UMMER” command in the “COME” session led to an increase in response time to other commands.

Handling External Distractions

External distractions can adversely affect the efficiency of training with shock collars. Some techniques and strategies can be used to maintain the dog’s focus and responsiveness during the training. The following are the most efficient ways to avoid distractions and enhance the results of training.

Gradual Exposure to Distractions

Distractions should be introduced gradually. At first, training has to be conducted in the controlled environment with as few distractors as possible. At this stage, a quiet room can be considered as appropriate. As soon as the dog shows consistent responses, new distractions have to be introduced. They can start with practicing in a backyard and then change to a public park. According to some CPDT-KA calculations, dogs, which were trained using the technique of gradual exposure to distractions, were 40% more likely to stay focused att he most highly disstracting scenarios.

High-Value Rewards

The use of high-value rewards can be an effective way to avoid distractions. With this purpose, the trainer can use some special rewards that will be more interesting to the dog than standard treats. For example, if a dog is being trained in a park with numerous distractions, pieces of chicken or cheese can be used instead of the kibble.

Controlled Training Environment

A friend of the trainer can be asked to walk by at a distance, while the dog is praciticing the commands. If the dog remains focused, it has to be rewarded. The distance can be decreased and the distraction can be increased during the practice. According to a study, which was conducted in 2019, dogs, who were trained with controlled distractors, showed a 50% increase in commant retention.

Real-life Application Example

A real-life example can be relevant to the SD training. In particular, the dog has to be trained ignoring food being dropped on the ground. At first, training with a single piece of food has to be provided in a quite room. Gradually, a busy room or a kitchen during meal preparation can be conisdered as training environment. Addition of the use of high-value treats will help to avoid distractions. In six weeks, the dog will be able to perform the tasks in public places.

Quantitative Monitoring of Progess

The use of the system of tracking the progress can be of great assistance. In particular, the performance of the dog during various distracton environment has to be registered. A system of ranking from 1 to 5 can be used to rate the focus performance, so that he rating has to be improved. Trainers, who use the quantitative monitoring method, show a 30% increase in success rates.

Ensuring Collar Safety and Comfort

The safety and comfort of the shock collar are uppermost in training a dog humanely, and correctly using a collar means knowing how to fit it, what materials to use, and how to monitor them.

Proper Fit and Adjustment

The first necessity is that a shock collar is fitted correctly. This ensures both that it does the job and the dog is comfortable. A collar that is too loose will not work, and a dog collar that is too tight will cut or chafe the dog’s throat, possibly leading to a pressure sore. It is important that a shock collar is adjusted so that, with the right amount of tension the dog collar fits accurately but not too tightly. one can allow two fingers to fit between the collar band and the dog’s neck. Research suggests that insufficient adjustment is the most common cause of neck injuries – a 2020 study found that in 15% of cases of shock collar use leading to neck injuries it was improperly adjusted.

High-Quality Material

Next, the collar material is selected. It should be durable, hypoallergenic, and non-reactive. A collar made out of medical silicone is of high quality and comfortable to the touch. And lower-quality dog collars are generally made from cheap biothane, frequently causing skin rash. Wearable and clean, having highly attractive convenience and can last a long time, silicone is particularly guaranteeing low-reactive properties for the skin.

Monitoring and Potential Maintenance

It is important to monitor the collar regularly and to maintain its condition. It is important to check and ensure that is not worn or damaged, and to clean the dog collar and the electrodes regularly to prevent a skin infection. It is important to ensure the dog electric collars are functional and the battery charge does not run out regularly – in a real-life situation, a pet owner notices that the dog is not as responsive as it was and once changes the collar as the parts are worn and the collar is diminished in its effectiveness.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account