4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


6 Facts About Spray Dog Collars

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » 6 Facts About Spray Dog Collars

Utilizes Dog’s Sense of Smell

Spray collars are devices designed primarily for training and behavior modification in dogs. They function based on targeting a dog’s highly developed sense of smell. When the dog shows an undesirable behavior pattern, excessive barking or aggression, the collar releases a specific scent that the dog does not like. The method relies on the dogs’ natural instincts to teach them the avoidance of such behaviors without causing any physical harm.

Key Components of Spray Collars

Spray collars are composed of a reservoir, a sensor, and a spray mechanism. The reservoir holds a solution, which is usually made of citronella or lemon, as both of these scents are highly unpleasant and deterrent for dogs. The sensor detects specific behavior, such as barking, via either the vibration or the sound. By use of either vibration or sound, triggers the spray mechanism. The immediate association of the barking or other triggering behavior with the unpleasant scent is formed, effectively teaching the dog to avoid specific behaviors.

Effectiveness and Statistics

Spray collars have shown a significant effect, reducing barking by up to 88% in domestic dogs. According to a survey of pet owners, during the first week of use of the citronella spray collar, around 68% of the owners reported a decrease in the frequency of their dogs’ barking. The high rate of effectiveness of the devices can be expected if used consistently as one of the training methods.

Real-World Applications

In the real-world scenario, the spray-collar use can be most advantageous in the household situation with multiple dogs. The excessive barking of one dog would create interference and significant stress for the other dogs. If a household has both dogs and cats, the use of a spray collar on a dog will prevent the frequent barking that could make the cats feel anxious.

Pros and Cons

Although most sources claim the spray collars to be safe, some consideration and comparison should be taken into account. The advantages of the use of such mobile devices include the lack of physical punishment and the ability to give the immediate feedback. The limitations can include the dog’s capacity to totally ignore the unpleasant smell, or the barking or other behavior that triggers the spray might not be associated with the application of the collar and be caused by external noise or other dogs’ barking.

Harmless Spray Emissions

It is natural to be concerned that a collar designed to spray a substance in a dog’s face might be harmful. It was designed to be safe, resorting to sprays that are not harmful for neither for the animal nor the environment. The most common sprays are citronella, water, or unscented, and they have proven to be effective in deterring unwanted behavior, without actually harming the dog’s body or compromising psychological health.

Composition of Spray

As Pullano and Cannas indicate, the most common type of spray used in various training collars is citronella. Citronella oil is derived from the leaves of lemongrass and is considered by the EPA to be safe and non-toxic repellent. It causes no allergic reactions and has no known effects that would negatively impact a dog’s health. The alternative spray is a blast of unfiltered water, which is not dangerous and works only as an irritant due to its unpredictability, not evaporating immediately.

Effects of Spray Components

The blast of citronella or water acts immediately, which is one of the reasons why it is efficient. When a dog starts barking, the canister emits the spray, to which the dog usually reacts by looking away. It is used as an attentivity-getter and centers the dog’s attention, interrupting the process that triggered the punishment automatically. The spray is not the caustic liquid that might damage nasal cavities and is not the chemical compound that affects body and mind chemistry. It is simply an olfactory stimulus that bothers a canine’s sense of smell and makes it cease the unwanted behavior.

Environmental and Health Safety

The chemical compounds on the spray are also environmentally safe. In case of citronella, it is a naturally derived oil that does not persist in the environment. There is no way it would be damaging to the pet or leaving a lasting mark on the environment. The health safety is proven by the studies results cited by Pullano and Cannas, that unequivocally testify to the sprays neither doing any harm to dogs’ respiratory systems nor causing any known effects in human respiratory system.In practical applications, the use of spray collars is a solution to problems with dogs barking. Pullano and Cannas illustrate the life of an urban species. The noise in the apartment hallway started becoming a serious issue, and the citronella spray collar helped keep peace without providing any permanent harm to the pet.

Tone Correction Option Only

Collars emitting a spray along with a tone correction implies a unique type of behavior training which uses sound as an antecedent to spray. This feature is beneficial, as it gives a chance to the dog to change its behavior voluntarily. On one hand, it minimizes the number of sprays and accelerates the training process, as the dog learns faster to behave in the right way.

How Tone-Only Option Works

Such collars have a dual command mode. At the first stage, when the undesired behavior starts, for example, the dog barks or jumps, the collar emits a warning tone. If it continues, the spray is released. The dog learns to associate the tone with the following response. Hearing the tone, it will stop barking or doing anything else which led to it.

Advantages of the Tone-Only Option

The main advantage of the given feature is minimizing the spray. A sensitive dog breed may like it. Since its use is decreased, it makes the collar more popular in the eyes of the owner, as he does not have to frequently go shopping to buy a new spray or a battery. On the other hand, it is less harmful to the environment if it uses consumable constantly.

Data and Case Studies

When a study was conducted using 40 dogs who showed nuisance barking, and they were trained both with tone-before-spray collars and a spray-only collar, the first group of dogs reduced barking behavior by 30% faster. Apparently, it can be viewed as the result of the fact the tone is quite disturbing per se and stops the undesired behavior without the need of subsequent spray.

Practical Implications

It has a significant practical application in rural areas, where it is desired that the dog is inactive. A good example is a nighttime barking, as with the spray-only option, a family may suffer from the sound.

Affordable Choice

Spray collars are regarded as an affordable solution for pet owners as they help avoid more expensive options, such as using high-tech tools or hiring a professional. Such a collar may become an excellent pick for those who require an accessible solution to such common issues as dogs’ barking and aggression without investing a lot of money into it. Here, we will assess the costs associated with buying a spray collar and discuss the most viable maintainance options.

Cost Ancillary

The price of a spray collar is substantially lower than seeking a professional’s help or using a high-tech tool. Trainers typically charge $50-100 an hour, whereas spray market estimates vary from $30 to $100 depending on the type and manufacturer. Purchasing a decent collar may save hundreds of dollars while potentially helping to remove a lot of economic burdens derived from dogs’ behavior.


A spray collar is supposed to be a durable tool, which would not require frequent maintenance and replacements. There are two types of collars: with citronella and the ones that produce no smell. In both cases, the cost of replacing a canister with a spray is around $10-$15. A can is supposed to help the owner to spray the liquid around 300 times, which means refilling the can would take place at least twice a year.

Market trends and consumers response

Surveys show that spray collars are among the most frequently sold collars in pet stores, whereas market trends suggest that up to 50% of all collar units in certain pet stores account for spray collars.Consumers are satisfied with the presence of such goods on the market and report on substantial success in avoiding common problems. Owners claim that such collars help to stop the barking of their dogs, which confirms that spray collars may be viable ways to avoid large expense rates. Only one collar would suffice to prevent undesired behavior in the case of several pets living in the same household. The costs of such a tool are lower than having to spend money on numerous training sessions for different animals (for example, for three dogs).

Requires Frequent Refills

It is correct that spray collars are effective, but it is not less true that they need to be refilled frequently. The required frequency is higher if the device provides training or control for at the beginning of training or when the dog displays some extremely undesirable behavior. The required frequency of refills affects the overall convenience of using a spray collar and the cost of the device’s operation.

Refill Frequency and Process

The standard spray collar canister has about 25-30 sprays. While it varies depending on a particular model; in any case, for a dog barking too much, the owner will have to refill the device about each week or two. The refill process is simple enough: one needs to buy a replacement canister that could be found in most pet stores or ordered online, ensure that the collar is off, remove the empty canister, and attach a new one.

Cost Implications of Frequent Refills

The refill cost is quite low, just like $10-$15 each, but the user will have to refill the device dozens of times, all in all. These costs are not sustainable in the long run, especially if a spray collar is their most helpful training tool. In the case of refilling being required each two weeks, the annual cost would be $130-$390. The number varies depending on the frequency of use and the kind of spray.

Managing the Refill Frequency

It is undebatable that the need for refills can be mitigated if a pet parent employs the spray collar in tandem with other training techniques, e.g., commands or positive reinforcement. In that case, the refill frequency will be lower, and the refill quantity will be quite enough to avoid damages to the various components of the collar.

Operation Costs and Training Effectiveness

The use of a citronella spray collar with a medium sized dog barking too much required bi-weekly refills at first, but the barking became less frequent, and so did the need for them.

May Reduce Effectiveness

Dogs and Spray Collars

As the result of extensive use of spray collars, the amount of efficacy of such method would change. With time, pet dogs grow accustomed to the trigger “events”, whether it is citronella, unscented, or water-based. It is imperative for pet owners to be aware of such process of desensitization and be able to apply other training methods. This training method has narrow use, unless unaccounted factors would constantly change – yet such would be simplification of inherent desensitization mechanism.

Dog Desensitization

Most cases of desensitization occur when a dog grows accustomed with the spray and would no longer fear such correction, thus not changing its habit. According to the study, about a fifth of pet dogs that used the spray multifariously kept the noise the same after six months since “initial impairment”. Tt is important to understand the limits of the methods and try other trainings to aid the situation. The more difference in training the better, as with time more traditional methods would keep using their efficacy because of variety in training commands. Before describing the case study, it is important to note that most cases the collar is designed not as a long-term help, but as a reset of a behavioral pattern tool.

Long-term Usage

My colleagues use one rescue dog as an example of long-term efficiency of the citronella spray collar. The pet dog had stopped fight against other dogs when it had been treated with citronella-spray collar. Moreover, the pet dog was able to correctly act by command. The puppy having grown, at first tried to escape after it had detected citronella smell.

In several months it became accustomed to the smell and again left without having reacted. Beside the permanent collar use, an occasional collar and a new command were used. Moreover, the owner put it on and off more often. The second training remained effective and with change in training dog first left when refused by verbal order. At the beginning of dry scent, it also helped: “the routine and the sight of the Spray Trainer”.. It is important for pet owners to try to check pet’s response and potentially change the training because of long-term use prospects.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account