4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


Are Chain Collars Effective for Controlling Large Dogs

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » Are Chain Collars Effective for Controlling Large Dogs

Chain collars can control large dogs if used correctly, reducing pulling by up to 50% with proper technique and training.


Chain collars are commonly used as a control tool for large dogs that are typically quite strong pulling or high-energy animals. They operate through a gentle tightening when the dog is pulling, which can help distract the animal’s focus back to the walker. The efficacy of the tool is very dependent on the situation and the behavior.

Efficacious Against Immediate Response

On larger dogs, usually over 60 pounds like Rottweilers and Mastiffs, chain collars can have a tremendously immediate positive effect. In the example of walking a 120-pound Mastiff, the handler could find the dog lunging toward other animals. A small pulling on the chain will correct this behavior immediately, tightening the collar briefly and successfully refocusing the dog . Studies suggest that after just a few such corrections, experienced even amidst the excitement of walking, pulling behaviors of dogs decrease by 50% .

Training Uses

A great many dog trainers use chain collars in a training context where the dog is being taught not to pull, that is, to heel when they walk. The effectiveness likely arises due to the immediate feedback of the dog learning that if it pulls, there will be an uncomfortable sensation on their neck. It is particularly useful in initial training as a small light tug, and people tend to be less effective at capturing the new environment’s attention in the dog with a word.

Long-Term Concerns

However, while the use is extremely effective in the short term, the degree to which a dog depends on the collar can vary widely with time. On the whole, consistent training that does not involve the collar always produces an exceptionally more obedient dog in the long term. Specifically, a dog trained with positive reinforcement, such as praise and treats, tends to continue well-behaved with or without a correction tool.

Use and Precautions

Appropriate use is essential for safely using chain collars, as over time, they can cause damage, such as injury to the trachea or the nerves in the neck. Collar tightness must be controlled through a technique of quick tug, followed by an immediate release, to ensure that no lasting pressure is put on the neck at any time. Dogs interested in getting a chain collar should consult a trainer with experience in their use. With a properly chosen collar and the support of a trainer, they can be a useful tool for control, providing communication and correction that many find invaluable in specific problematic situations. That said, they are a tool, not a lifestyle, and excessive or inappropriate use can pose risks to animals.


Training Method

Chain collars primarily function based on aversive conditioning, which is the use of an unpleasant stimulus to reduce unwanted behavior , that is in this case pulling on the leash. This is usually more effective with bigger stronger breeds of dogs such as German Shepherds or Labrador Retrievers, which may otherwise dominate in a walk due to their size and strength.

Immediate Correction Technique

In the immediate correction technique, a chain collar tightens around the dog’s neck when it attempts to pull forward. Tugging on the end of the leash applying a sharp amount of force causes a chain collar to become tighter around a dog’s neck. The success of this technique is dependent on the timing of the tug on the leash and the strength with which it is applied. The tug should be sharp enough for the dog to notice but not so prolonged as to be harmful or uncomfortable . Ideally, a swift tug and release technique should be used so that the dog receives a clear message of the association of pulling and the collar twisting dragging it out of balance. The immediate reaction to the unwanted behavior should continue to teach the dog to avoid such behaviors.

Consistency and Use

When chain collars are used, a lot depends on the consistency . During a training period which may vary from weeks to months, regular training sessions may reinforce the behavior. A study involving 30 big dogs demonstrated a reduction in pulling in 80% of cases if this collar was used as part of a 6-week consistent program. However, it is the consistent use which is important, and the training can not be discontinued prematurely as the dog can become encouraged to return to the bad behavior. Rewarding the dog with a treat, a praise with a pat on the head or more play with other animals . This style not only helps to reduce dependency on chain collars but also develops a warmer relationship between a dog and its handler. Knowledge of the mechanics of the collar will help the handler to use the appropriate amount of force and keep the timing humane. Misuse of chain collars with either inappropriately forceful tactics or too lenient ones can either cause physical injuries to the animal by causing tracheal damage or behavioral ones by causing the animal anxiety or aggression. Choosing the right size of a collar is important, and it should fit snugly around the dog’s neck without hurting it, with one or two fingers fit there allowing for a snug but not air-restricting fit .

Risks and Controversies

Chain collars, though effective in some training situations, also carry severe risks which lead to serious controversies and debates around their use. The most pronounced concerns of animals’ health risks related to an inappropriate use of this equipment . One of the most common issues is the design of these collars, which tighten when a person applies force to them. The most common injuries observed in dogs include the damage to the trachea associated with wheezing and difficulties in breathing and cervical spine injuries with the subsequent movement issues . According to veterinarians, dogs often suffer injuries as a result of the inappropriate use of a chain collar.

The most severe case known to them is laryngeal nerve paralysis provoked by the long-time pressure . Psychologically, these tools affect dogs via the use of an aversive approach. Over time, their use results in the increased stress level, fear, and anxiety of dogs. Behavioral specialist often report increased anxiety and aggression of the dogs raised with aversive methods. For example, if pain is used as a correction, a dog may start to associate its handler or a training area with a negative feeling. It might result in the animal’s aggression towards humans or other dogs in other situation when they are not even approached . A related issue is the debate on training methods, as the use of aversive methods forces an immediate response but does not help the dog to learn an alternative appropriate behavior. As a result, this method makes dogs obey with the collar but not outside.

As a result, the training equipment causes attention and risks and is not recommended. Many professionals recommend the use of harnesses, as they distribute forces evently and release the pressure on the dog’s neck. In general, the use of positive reinforcement leads to better outcomes and stronger bonds between a dog and a handler. Legal and ethical matters are also important, as some states have already introduced restrictions on the use of these collars. Such decisions are based on the concept of human treatment of animals where the welfare is priority and hurt is prevented.



In the quest to find effective and humane training tools for large dogs, several substitute chain collars have become quite popular. These tools aim to reduce the physical risk and emotional stress of chain collars training by applying less harsh methods of control and correction.


Harnesses are largely recommended for large dogs because it evens the pressure out instead of concentrating it on the neck and trachea region . The pressure is more evenly distributed on the chest and shoulders . Many harnesses come with front which redirects the dog’s momentum back towards the dog, making it very easy for the handler to direct it without causing any kind of pain or discomfort.

Martingale Collars

Martingale collars are a good option for dogs that easily slip out of the normal collars. It is made with an extra loop that tightens with the tension, which allows the chain to close around the back of the neck without choking the front. It is also an especially choice for dogs with narrow heads, like Greyhounds which can easily get their head out of common chain collars.

Head Halters

Head Halters control the dog’s head in much the same way that a horse halter works. When a dog pulls, the head is pulled back, effectively turning the body towards the handler. This harness allows the handler to effectively stop the dog from going one way or the other and control the speed of stepping. However, when the dog pulls, it may be harmful to the animal’s neck, so harsh pulling should be avoided. Padded Collars . These fulfill the same basic need as the regular collars and on the day-to-day walk may be a better option for your dog. Padded collars are studded with soft comfy material alongside that prevents any ridging or gnarling, through constant pulling, which only exacerbates the situation. . These fulfill the same basic need as the regular collars and on the day-to-day walk may be a better option for your dog. Padded collars are studded with soft comfy material alongside that prevents any ridging or gnarling, through constant pulling, which only exacerbates the situation.

Training techniques

We should also say that employing proper training techniques and lots of positive reinforcement can be more beneficial in the long run. There are many ways to reward good behavior, which can take the form of praise or a treat. It not only makes the dog repeat such behavior but it is also likely to improve the learning retention of the subject.

Professional Guidance

When large dogs need to be trained to behave properly, it is important to find professional help to decide if chain collars should be a part of their training, as certified dog trainers and animal behaviorists can offer their opinion on the basis of the latest research data and years of work with hundreds of different breeds and types of dog behavior. Given their experience, they can recommend the most effective training options that do not harm dogs of a particular size.

Choosing a certified trainer

Trainers that have certificates from organizations like IACP or CCPDT, are usually the ones who have gone through extensive training and who are bound by a code of ethics of a professional dog trainer. This means their methods are ethical, and their approach to training has evidence that it is effective. It is also important to choose a trainer whose methods are based on behavioral science and the learning styles of individual dogs.

Programs usually offered

Different large dog training programs vary from basic obedience to more specialized training that deals with certain behavioral issues (excessive barking, aggression, anxiety). When participating in these programs, a trainer assesses a dog’s behavioral issues, home environment, and owner’s goals to determine what training tools a dog needs. For instance, a dog that is anxious might be trained using a harness instead of a chain collar, and pulling will be prevented in a variety of safe and humane ways.

Case studies and success rates

A trainer who is good at their job will usually have case studies to prove its efficiency in training large dogs. They will also offer a success rate of their training method. An example of a success story could be a combination of tools that involved positive reinforcement, that reduces pulling and improves overall obedience in around 90 percent of cases in a normal cohort of trainees.

Ongoing training for owners

A good trainer will also offer training for dog owners. After training for dogs is over, a trainer offers follow-up sessions for the dog owner. They might also offer some at-home training tools and resources. For instance, monthly handouts, videos, and other educational materials can be really useful. Teaching owners to properly implement tools ensures more effective training. Good trainers also constantly educate themselves and are updated about latest research and teaching methods. They are aware that aversive tools aren’t necessary and their use is not ethical.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account