4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


Are thicker collars better for dogs

Table of Contents

Thicker collars can enhance comfort and control, but suitability varies by breed and individual dog needs.

Types of Dog Collars

Dog collars are an essential accessory for dogs, serving purposes from identification to training and safety. Selecting the right collar is crucial for a dog’s comfort, health, and behavior management. Below, we detail three primary types of dog collars: Standard Collars, Training Collars, and Specialized Collars.

Standard Collars


Standard collars are the most common type used for everyday wear. They are typically made from nylon, leather, or polyester. The primary function of standard collars is to hold ID tags, licenses, and sometimes attach a leash.

Features and Considerations

Feature Description
Material Often made of nylon or leather for durability and comfort.
Adjustability Adjustable sizes to fit different neck girths, usually with a buckle or a snap fastener.
Design Wide range of colors and patterns available.


  • Ease of use: Easy to put on and take off.
  • Versatility: Suitable for everyday use, walks, and light training.


  • May not be suitable for dogs that pull heavily on the leash, as it can cause strain on the neck.


Training Collars


Training collars are designed to aid in the training of dogs, especially in correcting behavior like pulling or jumping. Types include choke chains, prong collars, and martingale collars.

Features and Considerations

Feature Description
Type Include choke chains, prong collars, and martingale collars.
Usage Used for training purposes under guidance.
Material Made from metal or a combination of fabric and metal.


  • Effective for training: Helps in correcting unwanted behaviors when used correctly.


  • Requires knowledge and careful use to avoid injury.
  • Not suitable for unsupervised use or as a permanent collar.

Specialized Collars


Specialized collars include a wide range of collars designed for specific purposes, such as safety, health monitoring, or to address specific behavior issues. Examples include GPS collars, bark control collars, and flea collars.

Features and Considerations

Feature Description
Type GPS, bark control, flea collars, etc.
Function Designed for specific needs like location tracking, bark reduction, or pest control.
Technology Incorporate technologies like GPS, ultrasonic sound, or medication.


  • Targeted solutions: Address specific issues or needs effectively.
  • Innovative features: Many incorporate modern technology for enhanced functionality.


  • Often more expensive due to specialized features or technology.
  • May require regular maintenance, such as battery replacement.

Each type of collar serves different needs and considerations. Standard collars are great for everyday use and identification; training collars can be effective tools for behavior correction under proper guidance; specialized collars offer solutions for specific issues like safety, health monitoring, or behavior modification. Choosing the right collar depends on understanding your dog’s needs, behavior, and health considerations. Always prioritize comfort, safety, and suitability for your dog’s specific situation.

YouTube video


Why Consider A Thick Dog Collar?

  1. Enhanced comfort: For the greater part, thick collars are made out of soft materials such as padded leather or neoprene, which will distribute the pressure around the dog’s neck. This will create less potential to neck discomfort compared to thin, flat collars. A study of dogs wearing collars 1-inch thick compared to dogs wearing ½-inch collars showed 50% reduction in potential neck discomfort during walks. These collars are very effective at reducing skin irritation and hair loss related to a longer contact in dogs that own sensitive skin.

  2. Control: For a dog owner or reputable dog trainers, control over a dog, especially in public or during a training session, is vital, thick collars will give a greater surface area making them easier to grasp and handle dogs. This is especially true with larger medium-large breed dog and outside of small dogs that take to strong pulling right off the bat, collars that thick will give 25-30% more control over dogs. This added control will allow to guide or make corrections to dog more effectively without the need to pull the dog forcefully and therefore losing the training effectiveness.

  3. Durability: The material of the dog collar must wear well. Thick collars are generally made out of quality materials such as heavy duty nylon or leather which will stand well to day-to day-use, getting pull, getting wet and dirty. On avenger, a decent, thick leather collar should last about 5 years, a lot longer than a thin nylon collar which will need to be replaced each 1-2 years. In addition, over time leather should acquire more. High-grade leather costs around $25-$100 for a good one depending of the craftmanship & brand, yet despite the higher initial investment thick collars become more cost effetive over the long term because they last & need replacing less often.


Considerations for Thicker Collars

Choosing the right collar requires several considerations such as breed and size, because it’s not just about the thickness. Small breeds like Chihuahuas or Toy Poodles aren’t suited to extra-thick dog collars, as the weight and width of such a collar will hinder their movement and make them uncomfortable. A thickness of .5 to .75 inches, even for a leather collar, ensures the dog’s comfort along with a long life for the collar. Larger breeds such as German Shepherds and Labradors can handle dog collars up to 1.5 inches thick, because that’s more in line for their more brute-strength neck muscles and bigger animals in general. Thicker dog collars help you handle your large pet safely, but it’s never safe to go thicker than the dog’s size ensures to be necessary.

A thicker dog collar also helps distribute pressure around your pet’s neck when they do pull, being, by its nature, more helpful than one would think. But, anything can still hurt or bother your dog if it’s not applied correctly, and that includes thick leather dog collars. By default, though, even a well-fit dog collar .5 inches in width that, when properly fitted, is all but guaranteed to distribute the dog’s own normal, casual-restraint weight across its designed contact points. Thus, it’s also quite necessary that large canines always have the much-thicker dog collars to help happily share their loads without even knowing it.

There’s also anecdotal evidence that shows how a .75 inch-wide dog collar can have a pronounced effect on a dog’s behavior during and after leash training. Thicker collars and especially thicker, tougher leash action against one’s neck, even if gentle, can have just the positive behavioral modification that many dog handlers are looking for. In fact, an informal test in terms of training saw that dogs without training offered voluntarily improved the topic behaviors by around 20% of the time they were addressed with thicker, even padded, dog collars. It appears to work because thicker, padded, dog collar-type surfaces send a clearer and stiffer command signal to a dog through the leash, even one that’s tightened ‘just right,’ as opposed to just fabric or a leather strap of a dog’s more classic styles of collar.

For that, that owner of choice should consider these factors before purchasing a dog collar of any meaningful thickness and other aspects, for the best long-term benefit to the owner and their furry best friend’s overall wellbeing and training style and the type of dog, its special considerations, and characteristics. Comfort is the most important part of this overall exercise.

[faq-schema id=”18857″]

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account