4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


Do dogs prefer collars or harnesses

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » Do dogs prefer collars or harnesses

Dogs’ preferences vary; however, harnesses often reduce neck strain and improve control during walks, making them a popular choice among owners.

Understanding Dog Behavior: Comfort and Control

Dog body language and signs of discomfort are essential for owners to recognize when deciding between the two. Reluctance to move forward, scratching at the gear, whining, or an awkward gait may all indicate a dog’s discomfort. Dogs exhibit discomfort in various ways, and understanding these signs is essential to avoid behavioral and health issues.

Control: Training and walking are vital when deciding between a collar and a harness. Collars may provide more immediate top head control and are efficient in giving quick corrections in training. Harnesses provide better, broader body control and better force distribution, especially when walking . Studies have shown that harnesses result in decreased neck and tracheal stress, particularly in brachycephalic breeds that tend to have many respiratory issues .

Decisions for Different Breeds

Owners of small breeds mainly opt for harnesses with the realization they can provide safety without straining the fragile neck structures. A good example comes from a study that tested how many Chihuahuas enjoyed the harness and the collar which found that the dogs had their necks injuries reduced by 100% when the harness was used as the control gear . Owners of large breeds tend to want more absorption and the ability to manage their pets.

Adjustment tips

It is essential for regular collar adjustments to guarantee there is enough room for two fingers between the neck and the collar. The collar ought to be tight as ultimately it doesn’t simply slide over the dog’s neck, and also, it shouldn’t be too loose to avoid chocking. Harnesses may never rub in any case at the shoulder blades when ideally adjusted for dogs .

Owner experiences and preferences

Many owners of pets reported that their dogs pulled less while wearing a harness and enjoyed walking more. A survey involving 1,000 owners, mostly dog owners, determined that 70% of the owners said that their dogs respond well to orders when wearing the best harnesses that they do not cause damage like the collars . Veterinary advice often calls for choosing gear basing on a dog’s health and behavioral requirements. Training may call for using both a collar and a harness depending on a dog’s learning curve and behavior.


Types of Harnesses and Their Benefits

No-pull harnesses are a very popular option for owners struggling to control their dogs’ pulling behavior. They usually come with a front attachment which allows the walker to control the pet’s movement by steering it back the towards the walker whenever the dog starts pulling . “Walking on a slack lead is dangling,” meaning a no-pull harness subjects the dog to steer back to the owner when they pull. Research shows that no-pull harnesses can reduce pulling behavior by up to 50% , making walks more pleasant and less stressful for the owner. In contrast, vest harnesses cover the dog’s entire body and distribute pressure over larger areas. Since they are suitable for dogs with very sensitive skin or those that are susceptible to getting injured, it is not surprising that most owners prefer them in such a case. They are also more useful in colder climates as a source of warmth. Moreover, vest harnesses tend to be appreciated the most by owners whose dogs have anxiety issues which can be alleviated by pressure, similar to the way anxiety wraps work .

Choosing the Right Equipment for Different Breeds

Usually, the choice between no-pull and vest harness is determined by the dog’s needs. Naturally, no-pull harnesses are better for dogs that pull because they offer superior training and walking experiences. Vest harnesses would be more suitable for less energetic dogs that want to be as comfortable as possible. It the harness provides a gentle tug that is said to have a calming effect due to its snug fit, no-pull harness is more likely to be the best option.

Adjustment and Fitting Tips

In case the no-pull harness has a front attachment, then it is crucial for the pet’s owner to make sure that it will be centered on the dog at all times. Owners also have to ensure that it is not too loose in order to avoid so-called underarm chafing. Especially, after the dog has been walking for some time, owners have to check the tightness of their pet’s harness fitting. In terms of the vest harnesses, the owner has to check if it goes right across the body without hindering the pet’s movement. At the same time, the vest has to be snug without being tight as it should not move along the dog’s body in order not to cause discomfort. It is crucial for the owner to monitor the dog wearing the harness during several hours to establish that it behaves in a relaxed and natural manner.

Owner Experiences and Preferences

Naturally, owners are more likely to prefer no-pull harnesses since they make walks more pleasant, and less stressful. Another, important factor to consider is the comfort of a vest-harness, especially for older pets and those with skin issues.


Comparative Analysis: Collars vs. Harnesses

One of the foremost considerations when choosing between a harness and a collar is safety. A collar poses the danger of neck injury under circumstances when the leash is pulled hard and quickly, as the force is exerted upon the neck. According to several studies, continuous use of a collar on a dog that pulls often could result in serious health problems, including but not limited to thyroid damage, tracheal collapse, and spinal injuries . In turn, a harness distributes pressure around the chest and shoulders, vastly reducing any probability of physical injury.

Behavioral impact is yet another focal point of the current comparative analysis. A collar can be advantageous for training purposes, as it exerts control over the dog’s head, and subsequently, direction of movement . This control can be especially useful for corrections. However, harnesses appear to be better equipped for dogs with tendencies for respiratory problems or fragile necks, such as, for instance, Pugs and Bulldogs. They also make it easier to train puppies that do not yet heed advice to walk on a leash without quick pulling.

Selecting the Appropriate Tool for Different Breeds

Finally, the selection between the collar and the harness may also be heavily dependent on the breed’s characteristics. The former is preferable for large, strong breeds as it affords stronger control and reduces the strain on the owner’s back and arms. The latter may be suitable for smaller breeds, or those too meek or restrained to require firm correction.

Adjustments and Fitting

It should be underlined that proper fitting is crucial for both types of the tool to serve their purpose without excessive harm or discomfort. When fitting the cotter, it is critical to ensure that it is neither too tight to impair breathing or swallowing nor loose enough for the dog to get caught slipping out of . The corresponding rule of thumb is to see that one can slide two fingers under the collar but no more. When fitting a harness, it should be snug for the dog not to be able to escape but not so snug that it would cut the skin or cause abrasion.

Owner Preferences

The choice between a collar and a harness can also be significantly affected by the owner’s experiences. Some dog owners report that the use of a collar was more efficient, especially in more urban settings where control has to be fairly stringent. Others find that harnesses make walks with dogs more peaceful, especially in cases of need to work with a more energetic breed that might otherwise injure themselves with the choke of a collar. Rather obviously, this decision may have a noteworthy impact on the quality of life of dogs and their owners. That is why the crucial thing to do is to choose the collar over a harness considering the needs of the animal and the specific situation.

Choosing the Right Equipment for Different Breeds

Small breeds: Sensitivity and size

  • Chihuahuas or Toy Poodles can be easily injured by collars, which put too much pressure on their sensitive necks.

  • A harness is a better option for these breeds because the pressure is distributed across the chest and shoulders; thus, there is a smaller chance of injury.

  • The harness must be lightweight, so the small and fragile animal’s frame is not burdened.

Large breeds: Strength and manageability

  • German Shepherds, Labrador Retrievers, and Rottweilers need a harness that can endure much force and provide sufficient manageability.

  • A no-pull harness is perfect for these breeds because it does not put too much strain on an owner, and it effectively curbs the strong pulling behavior of large dogs.

Adjustment and fitting

Collar fitting:

  • For both types of breeds, the collar should be loose enough to allow two fingers to fit comfortably, and it can not slip over the head of the dog.

  • The harness should fit well to avoid any significant gaps that could allow the dog to escape, but it should be adjusted not to restrict the movement allowed or the ability of the animal to breathe.

Owner experience and preference

  • Harnesses seem to provide dog owners, especially the ones with large breeds, a sense of security because they distribute the pulling force. Therefore, it is easier to control a robust and stubborn dog without hurting the animal.

  • In contrast, harnesses are also loved by the owners of small breeds due to their gentle effect and the reduced risk of neck injury.

Expert recommendations

Experts suggest that people should opt for a harness for both types of breeds with a quick-release buckle for safety and ease of use. The material should be padded to protect the animal’s skin and reflective for use in the night. Squillante & Crumlish suggest that the material should be durable yet comfortable; thus, nylon or leather is the most suitable.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account