4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


How Do Chain Collars Compare to Prong Collars in Dog Training

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » How Do Chain Collars Compare to Prong Collars in Dog Training

Chain collars correct via choking; prong collars pinch gently, offering more control with less force, reducing pulling by up to 50%.

Chain Collars (Also Known as Choke Chains)

Chain collars, or choke chains, belong to traditional tools used in dog training. These items are meant to be training collars that apply choke as a type of correction for quick use. They are manufactured from different materials, including steel or metal alloys and are sold in various widths and lengths to fit different breeds and sizes.

Purpose and Use Chain collars, when pulled, serve the function of choking down on the dog’s neck or providing a check. The primary goal of such a tool is to put a damper on behaviors that are unwanted by delivering a sensation that makes the dog want to avoid pulling. In other words, if a dog approaches the end of his leash or lunges, the correction will deter the behavior for future instances.

Practical Application in Everyday Training Dog trainers often use these tools when quick corrections are called for in the case when a dog on a walk pulls too hard on his lead. For example, a 70-pound Golden Retriever that gets too interested in a squirrel and into its chase will need a correction to make the canine stick with the handler. The task will be addressed with the help of a chain collar composed of links of medium width, approximately 3 mm in width. Chain collars made of medium-thick links are resilient enough to not snap, injure the dog, or strangle him if used by a professional, attentive trainer.

When comparing chain collars with prong counterparts, it becomes apparent that the latter concentrate too much pressure into a limited number of points around the neck. With chain collars, the pressure applied is divided more evenly over the neck area. Still, if either tool is applied improperly, they can cause harm or discomfort. Nevertheless, according to studies and reports from trainers, chain collars have the potential to eliminate more than 70% of pulling behaviors. It should be noted that for a number of dogs, the harm is too great to use, since even if chain collars are properly applied, inappropriate or too frequent use leads to long-term injuries and worsened behavior due to stress and anxiety. In such cases, positive reinforcement should be used as a better alternative.


Prong Collars (Also Known as Pinch Collars)

Prong collars, or pinch collars, are a type of training tool commonly used among dog trainers to control strong, stubborn, or difficult-to-train dogs. These collars consist of a series of metal prongs that are designed to apply a gentle pinch to the dog’s neck when pulled, mimicking the corrective behavior of a mother dog towards her pups. They are generally more effective than choke chains and are comparable to e-collar stimulation in terms of pressure and severity.

Important Features

The most important features of prong collars are related to their physical impact. The design includes blunt prongs that never injure the dog but always apply an uncomfortable pressure: while tension is applied or when the dog tries to take off in a run. The leather loop, which tightens around the dog’s neck when pulled, requires proper readjustment while the links can be added or removed to suit different-sized dogs.

Application in Training

To illustrate the application of prong collars in everyday training, a real-world scenario involving an 80-pound Boxer who becomes aggressive towards other dogs while walking will be considered. The trainer would apply the prong collar to control and correct the dog; when the dog displays aggression, the trainer would apply a firm correction to the collar . Such a method usually results in a 50% reduction in aggressive outbursts during the first several weeks of training.

Comparison to Other Tools

When compared, prong collars are more effective and offer a clearer method of correction than chain collars. They also enable the handler to affect such corrections without as much strength or effort. In terms of their impact on the dogs’ well-being, prong collars are considered less stressful than choke chains.

Safety Considerations

As previously mentioned, the most important feature of using a prong collar is to ensure that it is always readjusted properly to rest right behind the ears and under the jaw. The collar should be fitted snuggly, but not tightly. The collar also should only be used in quick, abrupt corrections: sustained pressure is harmful to dogs and causes stress or injury.

Effective Methods

Using prong collars is also more effective when adjusted: the collar should never be left to hang loose or be constantly tight. The dogs should associate the pinch with specific training and the ability to avoid the feeling by following the command. The use of prong collars as everyday wear is not recommended.

Ethical and Humane Considerations

The use of prong collars has been a source of debate between pet professionals before. Critics point out that the device can be harsh and damage the emotional life of the dog, with an estimated 1 in 20 dogs refusing to walk when put on a prong collar. Proponents counter that, when used correctly, prong collars effectively communicate with dogs on their own terms and are even more humane than other tools. For example, within two years of its formal inception, electric stimulation through e-collars is now considered illegal across the UK.

Usage Recommendations

It is of utmost importance to consider one’s dog’s specific needs and behaviors when choosing between chain collars and prong collars for training. Besides, the existing level of training experience and the ultimate training goals also play a vital role, as both types of collars have distinct advantages and require different techniques of use.

Main Factors in Choosing a Training Collar

  • Dog’s Temperament and Size: A prong collar may be more beneficial for stronger, more stubborn or larger dogs since it provides more control with less force. At the same time, chain collars may be sufficient for dogs that require lighter corrections for obedience training.

  • Training Objectives: If the person’s goal is to reduce pulling during walks, a prong collar may yield quicker results with less distress for the animal. However, a chain collar may be more appropriate for training in a more controlled and calm environment.

  • Trainer’s Skill Level: According to guidelines on how to use chain vs. prong colllars, a prong collar requires bestowing corrections with exceptional timing to ensure they are perceived correctly. In turn, the chain collar can be used by less experienced or even novice trainers, although it is also possible to make mistakes.

Effective Techniques of Using Chain and Prong Collars

Chain Collar: The person should make sure that the chain collar is of the right size on the dog’s neck and is placed at the back of the dog’s neck below the ears. The collar should not be allowed to slip to the mid-neck down as it can lead to coughing or gagging . Training with chain collars requires the person to use short and quick corrections followed by an immediate relaxation of the tension to teach the dog that he or she should behave calmly to be comfortable.

Prong Collars: The right fitting of the prong collar is even more important, and the prongs should be always blunt. The collar should be placed snugly right behind the dog’s ears. With regard to training, the person should be gentle and bestow minimal pressure with prong collars since they are more efficient and should be used with the moving away-not-near technique.

Safety and Ethical Concerns Although both types of training collars can be used effectively, they all carry a risk of injury if used wrong. According to vet guidelines for aloo dog training , the risk includes tracheal damage, nerve injury or psychological distress. It will be imperative for the trainers and dog owners to use these tools as a part of holistic training process that also involves positive reinforcement.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account