4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


How Effective Are Bark Collars for Small Dogs

Table of Contents

Bark collars can be 70-90% effective for small dogs, but success depends on the dog’s temperament and consistent use by the owner.

Effectiveness of Bark Collars for Small Breeds

Success rates and limitations

As it was already mentioned, bark collars are effective as they prevent the cases of excessive barking. It has been stated that they have a success rate of 70% to 90%. Yet it is not a 100% effectiveness as people have different experiences when it comes to using bark collars. It implies that some products are more powerful and work better for some owners and less efficiently for others . It depends on the particular collar whether it will be useful for a certain dog. The success of a product depends on its type, while the latter should condition the effectiveness of the former.

Impact Factors

The effectiveness may be influenced by a variety of factors, and it appears that some products are less successful due to the way they were used . Tthe type of bark collar is important as there are electrocuting varieties as well as collars that vibrate slightly. There are sound-emitting collars that are effective for certain dogs. It is an important factor that has a direct influence on the effectiveness of such devices. An owner should also be consistent and use the collar regularly for his/her pet to receive appropriate training. Many owners may not be prepared to do this, and their dogs will not stop barking . It is crucial to remember that not all pets are the same, and many dogs may get used to constant corrections. One should note that several factors may impact the effectiveness of bark collars for small breeds.


Safety Considerations for Small Dogs

Possible Dangers and Safety Considerations

In the case of using bark collars for small dogs, there are possible dangers of the apparatus and safety issues that should be properly addressed. The use of the device can result in the dog’s skin irritation or even burns if the collar is placed on the pet for a long period. It should be noted that the use of tight collars also results in a similar effect. From a psychological perspective, the use of the collar may provoke anxiety or stress in dogs due to fear or pain inflicted by the vibration or shock . The measures of precaution that can be taken by the owners include the following:

  • Regular checking the neck of the dog to detect inflammation or discomfort;

  • The initial use of the collar for short periods of time, and then increasing this time after the dog gets accustomed to it;

  • The monitoring of the dog’s behavior to detect how it reacts to the collar, and adjusting the use of the collar depending on the observed behavior .

Recommendations for the Safe Use of Bark Collars for Small Dogs

Taking into account the discussed safety considerations and precautions, it is necessary to recommend using bark collars for small dogs taking into account the following aspects:

  • For ensuring the safety of the dog and the effectiveness of the device, it is advised to consult professional trainers or vet to determine what is the best and safest kind of collar to use it for your dog.

  • To avoid a harmful effect on the dog or additional stress, one should choose a bark collar that can be calibrated and adjusted in terms of the intensity level of the correction.

  • In case of the initial use of the device, the owners should monitor the dog’s behavior and the changes in barking during training.

  • The use of the device or correction should be combined with the measures of operant conditioning of positive reinforcement.

YouTube video


Alternatives to Bark Collars

Alternatives for Excessive Barking

Small dogs have a tendency to bark excessively and although bark collars are commonly used to manage the problem, training, and behavioral techniques can be a useful alternative. Positive reinforcement training includes rewarding the desirable action – in this case, being quiet – with a treat, praise, or play. This training technique can help to reinforce good behavior and tighten the bond between the dog and the owner.

Desensitization and counter-conditioning, in turn, is a behavioral technique that reduces the small dog’s response to the stimuli that trigger excessive barking. The method involves gradual exposure to the stimulus in a controlled environment so that the pet associates the object or situation that causes barking with a positive experience. A combination of these techniques can provide positive results in managing the undesirable behavior.

Ultrasonic bark control devices can also be considered as an alternative to bark collars. These objects include free-standing units, birdhouse objects, or other items with an integrated ultrasonic device that releases unpleasant high-pitch sounds when the dog barks. The audio is inaudible to the human ear but irritating for the dog. A similar non-collar device is an automatic treat dispenser that releases a small portion of the pet’s favorite treat or kibble, which incentivizes the dog to be quiet and distracted from barking. Both training and behavioral techniques and objects are humane means of dealing with excessive barking.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account