4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


Is a collar or harness better for a dog

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » Is a collar or harness better for a dog

The choice between a collar and a harness depends on the dog’s size, breed, health, and activity level. Both have pros and cons.

Understanding Dog Collars

Dog collars are a fundamental accessory for dogs, serving various purposes from identification to training. They come in a range of styles, each with its specific use, advantages, and limitations.

Is a collar or harness better for a dog

Is a collar or harness better for a dog

Types of Dog Collars and Their Uses

Standard Flat Collars: Ideal for everyday use, these collars typically feature nylon, leather, or polyester. They can hold ID tags and connect to leashes. Prices vary, with basic models starting around $5 and high-end versions up to $50, depending on materials and brand.

Martingale Collars: Designed for dogs with narrow heads, such as Greyhounds, the martingale tightens slightly when a dog pulls, preventing them from slipping out. Prices range from $10 to $30.

Training Collars: Including choke chains and prong collars, these are used for training purposes to correct behavior. Not recommended for unsupervised use due to potential harm. Costs range from $8 to $40.

Smart Collars: Equipped with GPS and activity tracking, smart collars help monitor a dog’s location and health. They are more expensive, with prices from $50 to over $200, requiring a monthly subscription for full features.

Pros and Cons of Using a Dog Collar


Easy to Use: Most collars are straightforward to put on and take off, requiring no complicated adjustments.

Identification: Collars are essential for holding ID tags and licenses, crucial if a dog gets lost.

Affordable: With a wide price range, there’s a collar for every budget.

Variety: Available in numerous designs, materials, and colors, allowing personalization for your dog’s look and comfort.


Risk of Injury: Incorrect use, especially of training collars, can lead to neck injuries or choking.

Escaping: Dogs, particularly those with narrow heads, can slip out of collars if not properly fitted.

Skin Problems: Poorly fitted collars or those made from harsh materials can cause skin irritation or hair loss.

Ineffectiveness for Training: Some experts argue collars are less effective than harnesses for behavior training, as they do not provide the same level of control over the dog.

Exploring Dog Harnesses

Dog harnesses offer an alternative to collars, providing benefits in safety, comfort, and control. They distribute pressure more evenly around a dog’s body, making them ideal for training, walking, and managing health issues.

Different Styles of Dog Harnesses

Style Best For Price Range Materials Pros Cons
Standard Harness Everyday use and walks $15 – $50 Nylon, polyester Evenly distributes leash pressure May not prevent pulling in all dogs
No-Pull Harness Dogs that pull $20 – $60 Mesh, nylon Redirects pulling force without choking More expensive; requires fitting adjustments
Step-In Harness Small dogs and dogs averse to overhead harnesses $10 – $40 Mesh, soft fabrics Easy to put on; good for small, skittish pets Not ideal for larger, stronger dogs
Tactical Harness Working dogs, outdoor activities $30 – $100 Heavy-duty nylon Durable, with attachments for gear; high control Overkill for casual use; can be bulky
Vest Harness Small dogs, cold weather walks $20 – $50 Fleece, soft fabrics Adds warmth; comfortable Not for strong pullers; limited adjustment

Benefits of Using a Dog Harness

Safety: Harnesses are safer for dogs prone to neck injuries or respiratory issues. They distribute force across the shoulders and chest, reducing stress on the neck.

Control: Especially in no-pull designs, harnesses give better control over dogs that pull, making walks more enjoyable and safer.

Comfort: With various styles and padding options, harnesses can be more comfortable for dogs, reducing the risk of skin irritation or fur damage.

Training: Harnesses can aid in training efforts, offering gentle guidance without the discomfort or potential harm of a collar.

Health: For dogs with certain medical conditions, such as tracheal collapse, a harness is often recommended over a collar to avoid exacerbating symptoms.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between a Collar and Harness

Picking the right gear for your dog involves looking at their breed, size, health, behavior, and activities. This ensures their comfort and safety while providing you with effective control.

YouTube video

Dog Breed and Size Considerations

Small Breeds: Harnesses work well for smaller dogs by spreading pressure across their bodies and reducing injury risks.

Large Breeds: Large dogs, especially those that tend to pull, can benefit from no-pull harnesses for better control, though sturdy collars are crucial for holding ID tags.

Brachycephalic Breeds: Dogs with short noses, like Pugs and Bulldogs, need harnesses to avoid throat pressure and breathing issues.

Key Point: Choose based on your dog’s breed and size, with harnesses usually being safer for smaller and short-nosed breeds.

Health and Behavior Factors

Tracheal Collapse: Use a harness to avoid throat pressure for dogs at risk of tracheal collapse.

Behavior Issues: A no-pull harness offers more control for dogs that pull or show aggression, reducing neck strain.

Training Needs: While collars may suit specific training sessions, harnesses are better for safety and comfort during active training.

Key Point: Health and behavior guide your choice, favoring harnesses for specific needs.

Activity Level and Purpose

Walking: Harnesses add comfort and ease during walks, especially for dogs that pull or have respiratory issues.

Training: Though collars might fit short training sessions, harnesses are better for active training.

Adventure Activities: Durable harnesses with reflective features suit dogs engaged in outdoor activities like hiking or running.

Safety and Comfort

Ensuring your dog’s safety and comfort requires careful selection and fitting of their collar or harness. These aspects are crucial for their well-being during walks, training, and everyday activities.

Is a collar or harness better for a dog

Is a collar or harness better for a dog

Assessing the Safety Features of Collars and Harnesses

Safety features vary between collars and harnesses, influencing their suitability for different dogs and activities.

Breakaway Clasps: Ideal for collars, these clasps release if the collar catches on something, preventing choking.

Reflective Materials: Both collars and harnesses can include reflective materials, essential for visibility during night walks.

Padding: Harnesses often have padding to distribute pressure evenly and prevent rubbing, crucial for long walks or active dogs.

Adjustability: The ability to adjust the fit is vital for both collars and harnesses to ensure they are secure without being too tight.

Key Point: Safety features like breakaway clasps, reflective materials, padding, and adjustability are essential for your dog’s protection and visibility.

How to Ensure a Comfortable Fit for Your Dog

A comfortable fit is as important as the safety features of collars and harnesses.

Measuring Your Dog: Measure your dog’s neck for a collar and chest for a harness. Add 2 inches to the neck measurement for comfort.

Check for Fit: You should be able to fit two fingers between your dog’s collar/harness and their skin.

Material Choice: Look for breathable, lightweight materials like nylon or mesh for comfort, especially in warm weather.

Regular Checks: Regularly check the fit as your dog grows or if their weight changes. Adjustments may be necessary to ensure continued comfort.

[faq-schema id=”18458″]

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account