4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50

4.6 ⭐ on Trust Pilot | 30% OFF on all collars | Free shipping over £50


The 5 most comfortable collars for dogs

Table of Contents

Home » Blog » The 5 most comfortable collars for dogs
The five most comfortable dog collars include padded, rolled leather, flat, martingale collars, and harnesses, each designed for specific needs and dog breeds, enhancing safety and comfort.

Padded Collars

Padded collars are considered one of the best options for dog owners who might want to take an extra measure for the comfort of their pets during walks or daily wear. These collars include an extra layer of padding, usually neoprene or soft foam, which creates a soft buffer between the material of the collar itself and the dog’s neck. Thus, they practically rule out such risks as irritation and rubbing, which can be especially helpful if a dog has quite a delicate skin or not so much fur.

In the case of, for instance, neoprene padding, it is durable, enhances comfort, and can be around 0.5-inch thick, which not only absorbs the pressure around the neck, caused by leash pulling but also distributes evenly enough to prevent a collar from choking a dog and causing it discomfort. On top of that, cleaning padded collars is quite an easy task – some only require to be wiped with a wet cloth, while some others can be washed in a machine if need be.

Dog owners who already have the experience of trying this type of collar on their pets often notice the significant difference in the latter’s behavior – many Lab and Golden Retriever owners, for example, have reported that their dogs were suddenly too excited about going out and created no difficulties during the walk while with a different non-padded collar they would have shown signs of discomfort and overall resistance. Such an improvement in the quality of life of any dog costs between $15 and $30, considering the price of a regular nylon collar as an alternative, the discrepancy is hardly considerable.


Rolled Leather Collars

I would evaluate the benefits of rolled leather collars both from owners’ and pets’ perspectives. Concerning the pets, it is possible to evaluate this type of collar’s benefits concerning the breeds character, such as preventing matting and tangling. Rolled leather collars should be ideal with longer fur or breeds that have to prevent tangling around their neck. The most easily imaginable examples would be Collies or Shetland Sheepdogs who cannot afford to have their fur tangled around the collar and consequently matting. The rolled leather collar mainly characterizes the diameter of the leather, which is also high-quality and prevents irritation.

The leather’s diameter decreases the contact area to the minimum and prevents the fur’s friction and tangling. It is most comfortable for pets and can occasionally slightly increase the collar rubbing, yet preventing any tangling problems for pet owners. Owners might notice a small decrease in the time spent for grooming their dogs and detangling their fur. This problem can be minimized by several tangles and detangling sessions that can save pet owners a significant number of hours for months and weeks. Concerning my personal opinion, it is possible to assess an average 30% decrease in grooming time for rolled leather collars over a flat nylon type.

The price might differ and average between $25-50. The rolled leather collar should have a longer life span and incentivizes to buy it due to shifts in the money spent as owners have to switch nylon collars 4-5 times per 3 years against only one high-quality rolled leather collar. Comparing from an owners’ perspective, it is also essential that rolled leather collars have additional safety advantages. The collars are made of optimal materials and provide a robust base for the neck.

The collars also have secure fastening and do not loosen up, break easily and are consequently a safe purchase. Owners can observe their pets playing around and breaking collars. It is impossible not to also note the design advantages. The fact a rolled leather collar can never be dirty and unpleasant as issued by rubbed flat nylon types. Rolled leather collars are also of high-quality leather and on average come in sizes ranging as usual, and black collars. Pets’ owners can also enjoy the aesthetic advantages of a wide variety of colors such as red or blue and the possibility of matching the owners’ collars with their colliers and tags.

Flat Collars

Flat dog collars are the most widespread type of collars that exist on the market. The main reason for such enormous popularity is the balance between simplicity, functionality, and comfort that this type of accessory offers. Flat collars can be made of various kinds of materials, such as nylon, leather, or polyester, which opens wide opportunities for choice. For instance, nylon is one of the most durable materials; it can be resistant even to the dogs that like spending time outdoors. The comfortability is based on the simplicity and weight of the collar since there are no additional elements on the dog’s neck.

A simple and fantastic knack for everyday use is the flat collar. First of all, it is convenient to take off and put on, and also, it is easy to hang both the medallion with your contact details and the leash on them. Most often, this type of collar is equipped with a plastic quick-release buckle, which is necessary both for easy donning and removal in an emergency if the dog’s collar becomes wedged somewhere. In this case, the affordable price ranges from $10 to $20, which can also be considered an advantage. The ideas that the collar is cheap and, therefore, of poor quality are explained by the pricing policy of the manufacturers and do not correspond to reality.

An excellent collar option is, for example, a $15 nylon flat collar, which can last about two years with constant use. Furthermore, it can also be attributed to the advantage that these collars have an impressive variety of colors and models, from the brightest and complex patterns to the reserved colors. Those dog owners who want to make every accessory of their four-legged friend as close as possible to their character are also ideal for flat collars. Finally, it is crucial that flat collars are also beneficial for dogs, as they quickly get used to them because they are not itching, and the animal can fully move.

Martingale Collars

Martingale collars are an excellent option for breeds with narrow heads relative to their necks, such as Greyhounds or Whippets, where other types of collars tend to slip off too easily. Martingale collars provide an alternative to choke chains that is safer because it only tightens to a limited degree. Thus, it is still securely in place, but it is not choking the dog at any point. Owners of sighthounds have commented that such collars give them more control over their pets, and the animals are still perfectly comfortable. When the dog pulls at its leash, the collar tightens a little but not to the point where it will cause choking.

When the dog stops pulling, the collar will remain loose. The price of such collars ranges from $15 to $30. The price is attributable to the additional materials required, as well as a design that typically combines a flat length of fabric with a far shorter loop that will tighten as needed. Many owners find this price range fair given the relative protection of the martingale collar, as well as its control function. Moreover, such collars come in a variety of materials, including nylon, polyester, and leather. Nylon alternatives are particularly popular, given that they are very durable and can be easily cleaned for a dog that is very active and spends a great deal of time outside.

Finally, the proper size collar should be chosen. A martingale collar should fit comfortably around the dog’s neck but still allow the control loop to be adjusted. When the control loop is tightened to its fullest, the two ends should be close but not close enough to touch each other. The collar then performs as needed but is not strangling the dog. The specificity of sizing is particularly important in this case, given that the collar is still choking the animals.



Harnesses present a significant advantage in terms of comfort and safety over conventional collars and are especially good for those dogs that tend to pull or have respiratory or neck problems. The safety and reduced pressure on the neck and back stem from the even pressure distribution across the whole trunk, which provides a safer mean to control overall movement. Typically, harnesses are an attractive option for owners of puppies or smaller breeds, such as Chihuahua or Pomeranian.

For these owners, even the slightest pressure on the neck area seems dangerous, which is why they frequently opt for the safety of a harness. Feedback from these owners typically suggests that dogs take to a harness more readily than to a collar and exhibit significantly less discomfort and, subsequently, walk-induced anxiety. As for the prices, these vary with the material used, size, and complexity but are on average between $ 20 and $ 50. However, the advantages of a good harness typically outweigh the expense as a well-used $ 30 nylon harness may last over a year, if not several years, depending on use.

The greatest advantage of harnesses is that they couple effective training with safety and comfort. From this perspective, they are an excellent way to prevent dogs from pulling as the design itself provides enough discomfort to discourage the pulling behavior. According to the owners using the harnesses, the walking behavior improves within two or three uses. As a bonus, most harnesses are also reflective or brightly colored to increase visibility when walking at dusk or at night. Finally, the “double D” rings the harnesses are typically equipped with offer a varying number of leash options for different levels of control.

Pet-Themed Blog Highlights

Products for pets you may like

Shopping cart
We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By browsing this website, you agree to our use of cookies.
Xparkles dog collar size chart with common breedds

You haven’t added any charms or accessories to personalize your Xparkles collar. Click here to check out our range of matching charms.

0 Wishlist
0 items Cart
My account